Yes, I appreciate the irony in posting a link of my rant about Facebook on Facebook, but I am willing to accept your name-calling (hypocrite comes to mind) if you’ll openly consider my arguments:
Effect on Interpersonal Relationships
This is the one that bothers me most, as paradoxically, Facebook enables more frequent communication with more people. But I contend, what is the quality of these exchanges? By replacing face-to-face interaction with screen-to-screen, Facebook has essentially isolated each of its account holders behind a smartphone, tablet or laptop. However, these advances in technology have far outpaced our evolution, evidenced in part by the fact that rates of depression related to loneliness in the United States have never been higher. Contrast this with the “primitive” culture of Africa’s Maasai - while they may live in huts made out of cow dung and hay, they also have virtually no mental illness (or cancer, also amazing). Now, while I’d have a hard time trading in my “incredibly luxurious” one bedroom apartment (which doesn’t have a dishwasher, I might add) for a cow pie palace, if it meant that I wouldn’t get mental illness or cancer, if I meant that I could both rely on and contribute to the tribe, now those aspects of communal life are attractive regardless of which continent you call home.
Facebook also offers the (false) impression that you are keeping up-to-date with your friends and other people in your life. While this is true on some level, the information that you learn about people on Facebook tends to be inconsequential, and/or only a small sliver of their life’s highlights. Sadly, this phenomenon prevents people from getting together in person. Never was this more apparent to me at my 10-year high school reunion this past August. Out of a graduating class of over 500 students, I would say there were only 80-90 attendees at the reunion (not including spouses, etc). At a school where gossip was (and still is, you don’t ever really escape “The Ranch”) practically its own varsity sport, this was an incredibly disappointing turnout. And the reason I heard from everyone I spoke with who didn’t attend was “I already stay in touch with the people I care about. And for everyone else, there’s Facebook.” It’ll be interesting to see how the reunion business fares over the next 10-20 years, my bets are not favorable.
Effect on Manners
I can’t even count the number of times where I’ve seen an entire group of people standing or sitting together, with each person scrolling through their smartphone. I find this to be incredibly rude – that someone would think we were actually having a dialogue with one another while he or she perused over Facebook on a smartphone. Here we revisit the idea above, that in-person interaction should trump electronic. But if your behavior belies your words, remind me why we’re hanging out again?
Effect on Communication
Using the abbreviated versions of words in e-mails, texting, and other short form communications has led to poor spelling, poor grammar, and an overall blasé attitude toward the English language in the United States. Facebook, and particularly its status update, only reinforces this. Some common errors include:
- Misspellings – what’s wrong with this picture: Cemetary, Definately, Occurence, Priviledge. If nothing looks wierd to you, you might want to re-take third grade
- Wrong homophones – whether it’s for/fore/four, there/their/they’re, or to/too/two, each of these words mean something different even though they sound the same
- Acronyms – although entire conversations can be had using this shorthand, it doesn’t make it right
o Person A: “BRB”
o Person B: “OMG! WTF!”
o Person A: “2 BZ 4 U”
o Person A: “J/K!”
o Person B: “LOL”
In the same way that some parents send their children to French or Spanish Immersion schools (where they learn a second language in addition to English), are we going to get so casual in our use of the English language that the need will arise for Proper English Language Immersion schools? Someone please tell me the answer is no (and don’t just type N).
Effect on Reality
With services such as Foursquare, Yelp, and Facebook’s Check In, it is easy to reveal your physical location on the Web. Whether posting about the exotic city you’re visiting or the new gastropub down the street, you’re again presenting yourself as a certain type of person – basically bragging about how cool you are based on where you eat, drink and travel. In a sense then, is checking in better than actually going there and being there? Okay, maybe I’m being a little dramatic, but why are we all staring at tiny screens when we could be taking in everything that is in front of us?
Effect on Privacy
The issue of privacy can be approached both from the outside in, as well as the inside out.
- Outside in: social networking site updates permissions on what can and can’t be shared (usually resulting in more information being shared than less). Then half of my newsfeed is filled with people yelling at me in all caps telling me to GO TO ACCOUNTS THEN SETTINGS THEN SELECT… AND RE-POST THIS AS YOUR STATUS IF YOU WANT YOUR FRIENDS TO PROTECT THEMSELVES TOO!!!!!
- Inside out: Is anything sacred anymore? People will pretty much post anything on Facebook. One of the most awkward I know about was a friend of a friend who regularly posted about his cheating wife and subsequent divorce. Um, isn’t this something you want to keep behind closed doors? Guess not.
o I read an amazing book over the summer called Look at Me by Jennifer Egan. Definitely check it out if you interested in this subject, it presents a very interesting perspective on identity and reality in contemporary American culture, with social networks playing a large part.
Effect on Productivity
Among people who belong to social networks, one-third of the total time they spend on the Internet can be attributed to social networking activities. And, I would argue, the majority if not all of that time is spent on leisurely or recreational pursuits (i.e., looking at photos from a friend’s recent trip to Tanzania rather than updating a LinkedIn profile). Whether it’s getting involved in too many sites, visiting said sites too frequently, or reading every Tweet/post/status update since the last time you visited, hours and hours of time is wasted on inconsequential activities.
What is the takeaway from all this? I’m not really sure. But I do know that I want to actually experience my life rather than read about it on Facebook.